PDA

View Full Version : Dakine Bike Bag review/initial impressions




smoochy
08-22-2006, 05:48 PM
Setting: Vancouver and abroad
Plot: Go places with bike, ride
Characters: Max, Master Plan Dan

Prelude:
The past few years, i've had to travel a fair amount for work, usually for several weeks at a time, and usually to warm places that have sweet trails. My first travels were with a cardboard box, and involved hefty airline fees. To counter the flow of cash, i designed and made my own bike bag - a zippered rectangle of cordura that was stuffed with foam padding and required fork removal for proper fit. This bag worked well and protected the goods for about 2 years, during which time I still got charged handling fees, got sick of the elaborate disassembly and the lack of castors (American airports charge to use the luggage carts - to hell with that, i'll (grunt) carry.. my *gasp* bags...). that, and the arrival of a new, slightly larger bike forced me to make the move to the Dakine side.

Cresendo:
Nothing ensures that you will stay put better than making purchases that will enable you to wander. The first several months of ownership involved a) going nowhere, b) snowboarding my brains out and c) finally, going somewhere - New Brunswick in March, a truly bikeless enterprise. The first use the bag saw was actually by my good friend Dan, who had to ship a bike home from Ontario - his impressions are welcome here. Unfortunately, due to schedule changes, Dan did not get home before I had to leave for AZ in June - foiled! This time around, i guarded my case jealously, and have come through fire and water and Utah to my home away from home - with my bike of bikes...

Climax:
Considering that I'd never packed this particular bike into this particular case, and yet the whole ordeal only too about 30 minutes says alot. wheels, rotors, brake calipers, handlebar came off, axle spacers were inserted, small parts went into the internal pockets, a few strips of extra foam were tossed in to better pad the bike and the whole mess was laid down and compressed while the zipper made a strained path around the piping. some points and counter-points:

1a) the size of this thing is HUGE when it is sitting in your living room or when you are trying to squeeze it into an economy rental car.
1b) the size of this thing is less huge when you are trying to fit a big bike in to it, or when you see what retired American cruise goers take off the luggage carousel.

2a) the wheels on this bag, and the retractable handle make life better.
2b) the wheels on this bag, and the retractable handle make you shove a few extra things in - and then it gets heavy. and then you have to carry it down the stairs.

3a) it is really well made and tough, and i could feel the confidence in my veins as the zippers kissed each other in the corner.
3b) it is really well made and tough, but one critical spot got missed - the narrow corner on the wheeled end, floor side (opposite the long edge double handle) already has a hole in it because that's where it gets dragged when the luggage handlers don't feel like carrying 60+ lbs. this should be the same rubbery stuff as the reinforced areas.

4a) the zipper had a tendancy to skip teeth unless you are careful when closing.
4b) be careful.

Conclusion:
all in all, i'm really stoked about this case, and it has proven worth the cash already. lighter and cheaper than a hard-case, more convenient than my little flimsy sack, i'm stoked to use it again and again and again and again... and ride my bike at the other end of course...


Max




tFly
08-22-2006, 07:26 PM
I was looking seriously into one of these, as well as the thule hard case. I know someone who has the thule so i borrowed it to make sure my bike would fit(not having to remive the fork was part of the criteria). But alas, as the saying goes, no dice. Next it was off to the dakine site for some measurements and it was only marginally better than the thule and my bike may or may not have fit inside. In the end it looks like I'll be using cardboard boxes for the next little while until I find something tha will work.
ps. my bikeis a cove playmate with a 66 on it, to give an idea of wheelbase.

smoochy
08-23-2006, 07:22 AM
yeah, i was surprised that the fork was still a pretty snug fit for me too (150mm 2006 66), and i was reluctant to take off the stem to improve said fit because the headset is a pain in the ass to tighten.

of course, the rest of the bike fits with huge amounts of room to spare (perfect for shoes, pads and helmet).

Damage Inc.
08-23-2006, 08:57 AM
I have a Dakine bike box and have been very happy with it as well. Protects the bike well and is easy to move around. Only issue is that I do need to remove the fork to make it fit. (Large Heckler with a Sherman Firefly)

Used it 4 times so far and seems to be holding up well with no signs of wear. Cardboard bike boxes would only last one return trip before they were trashed.

Lots of looks and questions in the airport.

Also, WJ in Vancouver always want to charge me extra but their customer service has reversed the $40 charge both times.

ESHER SHORE
08-23-2006, 08:58 AM
only downside of the bag is weight at 13kg!!

cardboard bike box only 3-4kg

smoochy
08-23-2006, 10:47 AM
only downside of the bag is weight at 13kg!!

cardboard bike box only 3-4kg

the Dakine website claims 8kg (16lbs).

but then they also show a huge bike with a JR. T fitting easily inside...

Damage Inc.
08-23-2006, 10:57 AM
I haven't weighed the box alone but my bike, gear (pads/helmet/camel back...) and the box came in at 80# on the airport scale...

the Master Plan Dan
08-24-2006, 02:54 PM
Ahhh yes... I remember the trip quite well... as if perhaps... it only happened yesterday!

The thing rocked!

I fit tons of stuff into it, bike 2004 Shore w/ Super T Pro's, Armour, No helmet.. shoes... Cocaine and the little girl that I smuggled in from Russia!

In all seriousness... because I am "never" serious... it worked very well. I mean outside the super huge size... the wheels worked great and everything had it's place. The bonus is that it ends of being so heavy that the guys and gals at the airport can't throw it around unless they are Heman!

WJ never made me pay a cent and I even had the fine young lady at the baggage check say that the good thing to do was load it up with all the heavy stuff because it is considered "sporting goods"... read Snowboard, Surf Board, Hockey Equipment, your girlfriends extensive collection of tanning wear... that it costs you nothing extra.

My bike and all its contents made it back to the Holyland safe.

Storing the thing in an already small apartment is a challenge.

They need to make one that is brown with Arglye!

Max... get your arse back here... Oh and what is a Cresendo?

Cheers!

Dakine Rocks!

Shrew
08-24-2006, 03:01 PM
I got one for my birthday in May.. haven't used it yet... the one thing that frustrated me was when trying to fit 2 bikes.. you could ALMOST fit 2.. but then there'd be that one part that wouldn't fit.

great review!

biggles604
08-24-2006, 03:01 PM
Wow. That was a long climax ;)

Good review on something I have never managed to find any feedback on.

Jerry-Rig
08-25-2006, 12:18 AM
Ross the Boss got his Demo8 and P3 into the Dakine Bag.

Shrew
08-27-2006, 11:38 AM
Ross the Boss got his Demo8 and P3 into the Dakine Bag.

I don't understand how with the wheels... He's just full of supprises!

evanius
09-09-2006, 07:46 PM
I have been looking into a travel case - mostly at hard cases, though.

Anyone have any comments on whether soft cases like the Dakine offer enough protection? My initial thought was there is no way I'm putting a nice bike in a soft case.

It sucks if I'll have to pull the fork off. I can't see that my small heckler wouldn;t fit with the fork on, but I could see having to pull the fox40 off my DH bike. I would travel most with the heckler anyways.

Do you guys think I could fit 2 wheelsets? With one xc and one FR set, its almost as good as 2 bikes.

Lastly, any of you know the price on the Dakine? I haven't seen it in a shop yet.

Interestingly, I checked MEC figuring they would carry something. And they do, a sweet Trico case, but their price of $600 is way more than mail order at $300-330 US.

smoochy
09-09-2006, 09:49 PM
the dakine case is about as big as any hard case out there, so your fit won't change much.

with the extra padding i put in, there is no way you could fit extra wheels. but that padding got my bike there and back again without a scratch or a worry. for how much i kick my bike around riding, i probably didn't need the padding, but it stops the the deconstructed bike from rattling around inside.

the cost was around 300 or so. it's been awhile.

consider the weight too - the dakine bag is (claimed) 16lbs - hard cases are about double that.

Johnie P
09-09-2006, 09:59 PM
Claimed weight is way off. They are 27lb which makes them almost useless for international flights cause of weight restrictions.Unless you have a 24lb xc bike to put in it,the boxes are way to heavy.

smoochy
09-09-2006, 10:07 PM
i should put mine on a scale and verify... maybe.

Johnie P
09-10-2006, 11:26 AM
Ross might have an older case.they started making them smaller 2 years ago i think,to meet plane restrictions.