cam@nsmb.com
03-03-2005, 12:31 PM
Start at the bottom.
Dear Ms Craver,
The only 'authorized' trail on the North Shore is the Baden Powell. That means that all existing hiking trails (aside from the Baden Powell) as well as mountain bike trails that have been there for 20 years are equally legal or illegal depending upon your perspective. Your omission of this point undermines your credibility. It also means that if you hike off the Baden Powell your activities are just as 'illegal' as ours.
As far as being an easy target I would suggest that it is the disinformation you send publicly to council and fonvca.org that has mountain bikers notice you. You suggest that our motives for maintaining the Baden Powell trail are disingenuous and that we act only out of self-interest. This is terribly insulting and an absolute fabrication. We have no desire to ride the Baden Powell trail when there are much better trails for our needs close by. How can you be surprised by our reaction when you make statements such as these? It seems it is you who owes mountain bikers an apology.
I cannot take responsibility for the statements made about you on our bulletin board, just as someone who builds a wall cannot be responsible for what is written on it, but I would question what brings you there. Are you a secret rider after all or are you searching for information to further your slanderous campaign against us? That said I have never advocated unpleasantness and I regret if you have been subjected to this via email. Considering the emails I have been cc'ed on that have been sent to Councillor Crist I would suggest he's becoming more sensitive - they were at worst rather innocuous and often very polite.
You also claim to be environmentally active but your family owns two SUVs while your husband speaks out at council meetings against public transit. You also live in a low-density neighbourhood on the edge of the rainforest. This sort of hypocrisy leads us to believe that you care little for the environment and that your actions are motivated by a personal dislike for people having fun in your area.
Concerning your fear of the weather, a little research would show you that the trail construction techniques we employ (supervised by Graham Knell most recently) allow trails to be ridden in all types of weather with very little adverse impact. These techniques were employed on the Baden Powell section so dig out your boots - thanks to us you are free to hike in any kind of weather. Isn't that nice?
You may be interested to know that West Van Council recently approved the construction of a mountain bike riding area near the top of Cypress Mountain. It seems the new council has finally seen the positive effect mountain biking can have on the community and are guiding their actions accordingly. On top of this the resort at Cypress will be offering lift-accessed riding for the summer of 2005 - another vote of confidence for those of us who ride non polluting off road bicycles. I would suggest that riding in neither of these areas will be deemed illegal but I'm not certain how they will respond to hiking in the same areas.
I hope that in future you will start to speak the truth and avoid the slanderous campaign of disinformation you have employed thus far.
Please feel free to forward any insulting emails you receive from mountain bikers and I would be happy to respond to the sender and let them know that I abhor this sort of behaviour. There are bad seeds in every community and I would personally like to help educate mountain bikers who are impolite or worse so we can have more harmonious relationships with the community.
Sincerely,
Cam McRae
On 3-Mar-05, at 10:14 AM, M E Craver wrote:
Dear Mr. McRae:_ Where do you get off with lying?_ If I had wanted to do something like that I would have physically removed those NSMBA plates attached to the Lower Griffin Trail structures, and torn down the "plans"(attached to trees) for the modifying of the Lower Griffen, long ago._ The temptation has been there._ But that is not how I work. Be aware, Mr. McRae, I am not the only resident in this neighbourhood that is pretty upset about the "takeover" of our natural forests by your kind -- but I happen to be the most vocal -- hence, an "easy target" for you and your www. nsmb.com board. Fair?_ I do not think so. As far as I know, the neighbourhood got Trail Days "invites" in their mailboxes._ I received three, myself._ Of course, I declined -- for reasons you are aware of.
____ It is clear mountain bikers propose to ride on this trail, as I noticed a typical newly built mountain bike ladder bridge leading to a bike trail about half way up that section of the Baden Powell Trail. Frankly, I had not really noticed that trail before, but now that it has been "defined" for mountain bikes, we are sure to see more biking traffic coming through._ That is the point I am trying to make to Council._ I have encountered numerous mountain bikers on that portion of the trail over the years.
____ Also, I do not hike that trail during or shortly after rains. But I continue to see many mountain bikers coming out to ride in the park and trails -- rain, shine, snow, and at night (wearing halogen headlamps)._ It is not I who is being unreasonable, but you, the nsmb.com and the NSMBA, and other assorted mountain bikers. You do not want to leave Fromme, or any of the other eight areas of the North Shore you now illegally ride on._ Perhaps LSCR and portions of Mount Seymour are "legal" now? -- I do not know that for sure.
_ __ You and I do know, however, that it is true mountain bike trails have been cut illegally all over Fromme without approval from the DNV, in prior years._ So why should we be commending your efforts, now, because you "maintain" these trails with "approval" from DNV?_ The truth is the bike trails you ride on are still concidered "unauthorized" (DNV's terminology. Sounds nicer than "illegal", I guess).__ Frankly, some of the derogatory things said on your www.nsmba.com website about those who do not approve mountain biking in forest habitats_ -- approved by the moderator -- tells the whole story._ So please get off your high horse of arrogance, Mr. McRae._ From the things I have read on your website bulletin board about myself and Councillor Crist, along the nasty private e-mails that have come our way,_ it is you who should apologize to DNV and_ myself._ Thank you.
Monica Craver
Cam McRae wrote:
Dear Mayor and Council,
I see recently that you were sent a letter by Ms M. E. Craver, a local resident who opposes mountain biking. In her letter she complains about the work many mountain bikers completed on the Baden Powell Trail between Mountain Highway and Mountain View Park. One would think, seeing as this is her neighbourhood, she would be pleased with this project. Instead, in an effort to further poison council against us, she attacked the work done by 130 volunteers. On top of that she was seen removing notices posted in the neighbourhood informing area residents of the opportunity to come out and help preserve the trail and the environment surrounding it. These are not in my opinion the actions of a reasonable person.
This section of trail was by all accounts a mess. It had essentially become a creek bed because of poor drainage and virtually no maintenance. It's interesting to note that mountain bikers very rarely use this trail because there are other more suitable routes down the mountain for us. Our desire to maintain and repair this trail was motivated by a desire to be responsible trail users and as a means of showing the Council, residents and other trail users how we care for the forest.
Ms Craver states; " The mountain bikers’ political agenda is to ride this because they had a “Trail Days” on it. If the Baden Powell remained a hiker trail, I am sure I would have come out to help keep the natural beauty and definition of the trail." This is untrue. We have no desire to use this section of trail and this was not why the trail day was scheduled. It may be useful for Ms Craver to know that Graham Knell, the Trails and Habitat Coordinator for the District, was on hand during the trail day supervising the construction of the trail. It was not as Ms Craver claims maintained to be " a typical “rock armoured” bike trail. Good trail construction for hikers is very similar to good trail construction for cyclists. If Ms Craver was informed about trail construction she would have known this. While the work was done with hikers in mind it will certainly be more than durable enough to withstand the infrequent bicycle traffic the trail sees.
I continue to be encouraged by Councils efforts to consider these issues carefully and to listen to those who present reasonable arguments on both sides of this debate. The efforts of a few, using fabrication, slander and half truths do nothing to help this process and only encourage division among the residents of North Vancouver. I have quoted Ms Craver's e-mail in entirety below to illustrate this point.
Sincerely,
Cam McRae
Editor
nsmb.com e.magazine
Dear Mayor and Council: This is the mountain biker agenda I was talking to you about. This stretch of Baden Powell trail from the east side of the gravel service road to Mountain View Park was supposed to be a hikers’ only trail. The mountain bikers’ political agenda is to ride this because they had a “Trail Days” on it. The new trail looks a bit like a typical “rock armoured” bike trail, if you ask me. Remember, these mountain bike trail and structure builders had no problem building and cutting new trails the past several years all over Fromme – without any DNV approval. This is part of the mountain bike sub-culture. They are only wishing to benefit themselves, and not others. If the Baden Powell remained a hiker trail, I am sure I would have come out to help keep the natural beauty and definition of the trail. I, however, refuse to help any mountain bikers pursue their open agenda. Please do not fall for their ruse, either. Thank you. --Monica Craver-
Dear Ms Craver,
The only 'authorized' trail on the North Shore is the Baden Powell. That means that all existing hiking trails (aside from the Baden Powell) as well as mountain bike trails that have been there for 20 years are equally legal or illegal depending upon your perspective. Your omission of this point undermines your credibility. It also means that if you hike off the Baden Powell your activities are just as 'illegal' as ours.
As far as being an easy target I would suggest that it is the disinformation you send publicly to council and fonvca.org that has mountain bikers notice you. You suggest that our motives for maintaining the Baden Powell trail are disingenuous and that we act only out of self-interest. This is terribly insulting and an absolute fabrication. We have no desire to ride the Baden Powell trail when there are much better trails for our needs close by. How can you be surprised by our reaction when you make statements such as these? It seems it is you who owes mountain bikers an apology.
I cannot take responsibility for the statements made about you on our bulletin board, just as someone who builds a wall cannot be responsible for what is written on it, but I would question what brings you there. Are you a secret rider after all or are you searching for information to further your slanderous campaign against us? That said I have never advocated unpleasantness and I regret if you have been subjected to this via email. Considering the emails I have been cc'ed on that have been sent to Councillor Crist I would suggest he's becoming more sensitive - they were at worst rather innocuous and often very polite.
You also claim to be environmentally active but your family owns two SUVs while your husband speaks out at council meetings against public transit. You also live in a low-density neighbourhood on the edge of the rainforest. This sort of hypocrisy leads us to believe that you care little for the environment and that your actions are motivated by a personal dislike for people having fun in your area.
Concerning your fear of the weather, a little research would show you that the trail construction techniques we employ (supervised by Graham Knell most recently) allow trails to be ridden in all types of weather with very little adverse impact. These techniques were employed on the Baden Powell section so dig out your boots - thanks to us you are free to hike in any kind of weather. Isn't that nice?
You may be interested to know that West Van Council recently approved the construction of a mountain bike riding area near the top of Cypress Mountain. It seems the new council has finally seen the positive effect mountain biking can have on the community and are guiding their actions accordingly. On top of this the resort at Cypress will be offering lift-accessed riding for the summer of 2005 - another vote of confidence for those of us who ride non polluting off road bicycles. I would suggest that riding in neither of these areas will be deemed illegal but I'm not certain how they will respond to hiking in the same areas.
I hope that in future you will start to speak the truth and avoid the slanderous campaign of disinformation you have employed thus far.
Please feel free to forward any insulting emails you receive from mountain bikers and I would be happy to respond to the sender and let them know that I abhor this sort of behaviour. There are bad seeds in every community and I would personally like to help educate mountain bikers who are impolite or worse so we can have more harmonious relationships with the community.
Sincerely,
Cam McRae
On 3-Mar-05, at 10:14 AM, M E Craver wrote:
Dear Mr. McRae:_ Where do you get off with lying?_ If I had wanted to do something like that I would have physically removed those NSMBA plates attached to the Lower Griffin Trail structures, and torn down the "plans"(attached to trees) for the modifying of the Lower Griffen, long ago._ The temptation has been there._ But that is not how I work. Be aware, Mr. McRae, I am not the only resident in this neighbourhood that is pretty upset about the "takeover" of our natural forests by your kind -- but I happen to be the most vocal -- hence, an "easy target" for you and your www. nsmb.com board. Fair?_ I do not think so. As far as I know, the neighbourhood got Trail Days "invites" in their mailboxes._ I received three, myself._ Of course, I declined -- for reasons you are aware of.
____ It is clear mountain bikers propose to ride on this trail, as I noticed a typical newly built mountain bike ladder bridge leading to a bike trail about half way up that section of the Baden Powell Trail. Frankly, I had not really noticed that trail before, but now that it has been "defined" for mountain bikes, we are sure to see more biking traffic coming through._ That is the point I am trying to make to Council._ I have encountered numerous mountain bikers on that portion of the trail over the years.
____ Also, I do not hike that trail during or shortly after rains. But I continue to see many mountain bikers coming out to ride in the park and trails -- rain, shine, snow, and at night (wearing halogen headlamps)._ It is not I who is being unreasonable, but you, the nsmb.com and the NSMBA, and other assorted mountain bikers. You do not want to leave Fromme, or any of the other eight areas of the North Shore you now illegally ride on._ Perhaps LSCR and portions of Mount Seymour are "legal" now? -- I do not know that for sure.
_ __ You and I do know, however, that it is true mountain bike trails have been cut illegally all over Fromme without approval from the DNV, in prior years._ So why should we be commending your efforts, now, because you "maintain" these trails with "approval" from DNV?_ The truth is the bike trails you ride on are still concidered "unauthorized" (DNV's terminology. Sounds nicer than "illegal", I guess).__ Frankly, some of the derogatory things said on your www.nsmba.com website about those who do not approve mountain biking in forest habitats_ -- approved by the moderator -- tells the whole story._ So please get off your high horse of arrogance, Mr. McRae._ From the things I have read on your website bulletin board about myself and Councillor Crist, along the nasty private e-mails that have come our way,_ it is you who should apologize to DNV and_ myself._ Thank you.
Monica Craver
Cam McRae wrote:
Dear Mayor and Council,
I see recently that you were sent a letter by Ms M. E. Craver, a local resident who opposes mountain biking. In her letter she complains about the work many mountain bikers completed on the Baden Powell Trail between Mountain Highway and Mountain View Park. One would think, seeing as this is her neighbourhood, she would be pleased with this project. Instead, in an effort to further poison council against us, she attacked the work done by 130 volunteers. On top of that she was seen removing notices posted in the neighbourhood informing area residents of the opportunity to come out and help preserve the trail and the environment surrounding it. These are not in my opinion the actions of a reasonable person.
This section of trail was by all accounts a mess. It had essentially become a creek bed because of poor drainage and virtually no maintenance. It's interesting to note that mountain bikers very rarely use this trail because there are other more suitable routes down the mountain for us. Our desire to maintain and repair this trail was motivated by a desire to be responsible trail users and as a means of showing the Council, residents and other trail users how we care for the forest.
Ms Craver states; " The mountain bikers’ political agenda is to ride this because they had a “Trail Days” on it. If the Baden Powell remained a hiker trail, I am sure I would have come out to help keep the natural beauty and definition of the trail." This is untrue. We have no desire to use this section of trail and this was not why the trail day was scheduled. It may be useful for Ms Craver to know that Graham Knell, the Trails and Habitat Coordinator for the District, was on hand during the trail day supervising the construction of the trail. It was not as Ms Craver claims maintained to be " a typical “rock armoured” bike trail. Good trail construction for hikers is very similar to good trail construction for cyclists. If Ms Craver was informed about trail construction she would have known this. While the work was done with hikers in mind it will certainly be more than durable enough to withstand the infrequent bicycle traffic the trail sees.
I continue to be encouraged by Councils efforts to consider these issues carefully and to listen to those who present reasonable arguments on both sides of this debate. The efforts of a few, using fabrication, slander and half truths do nothing to help this process and only encourage division among the residents of North Vancouver. I have quoted Ms Craver's e-mail in entirety below to illustrate this point.
Sincerely,
Cam McRae
Editor
nsmb.com e.magazine
Dear Mayor and Council: This is the mountain biker agenda I was talking to you about. This stretch of Baden Powell trail from the east side of the gravel service road to Mountain View Park was supposed to be a hikers’ only trail. The mountain bikers’ political agenda is to ride this because they had a “Trail Days” on it. The new trail looks a bit like a typical “rock armoured” bike trail, if you ask me. Remember, these mountain bike trail and structure builders had no problem building and cutting new trails the past several years all over Fromme – without any DNV approval. This is part of the mountain bike sub-culture. They are only wishing to benefit themselves, and not others. If the Baden Powell remained a hiker trail, I am sure I would have come out to help keep the natural beauty and definition of the trail. I, however, refuse to help any mountain bikers pursue their open agenda. Please do not fall for their ruse, either. Thank you. --Monica Craver-